Purpose. Ten libraries across the UK are participating in the first phase of an initiative to assess the impact of higher education libraries on learning, teaching, and research. The initiative is being undertaken under the auspices of the Library and Information Research Group and the Society of College, National, and University Libraries. This interim report provides an overview of the initiative and describes participation by two of the libraries: Glasgow Caledonian University and University College Chester. Design/methodology/approach. Each of the libraries has chosen an area of their activity where they wish to assess their impact. The ten participating institutions have then followed a common approach to assessing impact which involves specifying objectives for what the library is trying to achieve, determining success criteria, establishing impact measures, identifying what evidence is needed, and choosing methods for gathering evidence. Findings. Assessing a library's impact is not easy but the potential benefits can be considerable. Issues identified in the first phase include the time/resources needed, the importance of having good research skills, the difficulties of getting the evidence, and separating out the library's contribution. Benefits illustrated in the case studies include demonstrating that the library is supporting university strategy, building closer links with academics, and enabling staff to gain a better understanding of academic processes. Originality/value. The paper will interest library managers and staff who are concerned about the impact of their services and are seeking ways to demonstrate the difference that they make to their host organisations.
Article navigation
Conceptual Paper|
December 01 2004
Counting on making a difference: assessing our impact
Philip Payne;
Philip Payne
Head of Learning Support Services, Leeds Metropolitan University, Leeds, UK
Search for other works by this author on:
John Crawford;
John Crawford
Library Research Officer, Glasgow Caledonian University, Glasgow, UK
Search for other works by this author on:
Wendy Fiander
Wendy Fiander
Acting Director, Learning Resources, University College Chester, Chester, UK
Search for other works by this author on:
Publisher: Emerald Publishing
Online ISSN: 1474-1032
Print ISSN: 0305-5728
© Emerald Group Publishing Limited
2004
VINE (2004) 34 (4): 176–183.
Citation
Payne P, Crawford J, Fiander W (2004), "Counting on making a difference: assessing our impact". VINE, Vol. 34 No. 4 pp. 176–183, doi: https://doi.org/10.1108/03055720410570966
Download citation file:
211
Views
New and popular articles
Suggested Reading
ICT literacy
Reference Services Review (June,2005)
Using rubrics to assess information literacy
Reference Services Review (January,2006)
Business pedagogy: a qualitative analysis to inform library support
Performance Measurement and Metrics (May,2020)
Indicators for collection evaluation: a new dimensional framework
Collection Building (October,2008)
Developing a collaborative faculty‐librarian information literacy assessment project
Library Review (February,2012)
Related Chapters
The Relationship between Collection Strength and Student Achievement
Advances in Librarianship
Inclusive Assessment in Higher Education
Inclusive Education in South African Further and Higher Education: Reflections on Equity, Access, and Inclusion
The Librarianship Portfolio, Part Two: A Rubric for Evaluation
Innovation in Libraries and Information Services
Recommended for you
These recommendations are informed by your reading behaviors and indicated interests.
