Skip to Main Content
Article navigation

As distance learning, online learning, and hybrid courses become more prevalent, unexpected problems arise and solutions must be formulated. Many problems have been recognized and solved. Some are recognized, but no effective solutions have been formulated. The problems that appear to be addressed first are technical, not personal. This would lead to the conclusion that many student-based recurring problems that are not being adequately addressed comprise the overall problem of alternative learning—student education on appropriate and effective computer use, is highly lacking. This article will discuss one of the problems related to this overall problem and offer some solutions.

While distance learning has existed for many years, the problems unique to the use of the Internet are new and becoming more evident with the increase in its use for educational purposes. Many problems have been identified, such as accommodating the handicapped, addressing different cultural needs, keeping assessment requirements the same for distance and traditional learning, ease of cheating in distance learning, time zone differences, solving the need for hands-on lab work, special needs of auditory learners, students’ lack of technical knowledge, and communication protocol for e-mail messages, including clarity of intent on the part of the sender and understanding on the part of the recipient.

There are many challenges to appropriate e-mail communication; for instance, the tone of writing can be mistaken for the wrong meaning or that facts given without explanation can be taken as a strict statement or belief on the part of the writer when, in reality, the writer is simply providing research information found, and other e-mail protocols.

Researchers from New York and Kentucky discuss the importance of proper e-mail communication in the classroom, “students’ active participation is essential for learning to occur.… In e-mail communication, this includes both an understanding of the purpose of the activity and a willingness and motivation to take part in it” (Liqing & Boulware, 2002). As adults are introduced to this new method of communication, they have no background in the field and there is a shortage of instruction available to assist them when signing up for alternative learning that requires e-mail communication.

There are many solutions to this problem for adult learners. Solutions such as a prerequisite class on e-mail use and etiquette, tutorials available online, interactive computer-based training, and so on. These are short-term solutions almost like putting one’s finger in the hole in the dike. It will stop the flow of water, but something must be done to make the problem go away on a more permanent and stable basis.

Instruction on computer use should begin in elementary school. If students, starting in elementary school, were taught to use e-mail, they would grow to adulthood owning the skill. This would be a more permanent and stable solution to a growing problem.

In a study conducted with second graders, it was found that everyone benefited from teaching the students proper use of e-mail communication. The teacher was able to give individual instruction and feedback to the students, the parents eagerly participated, the students learned to use this method of communication to discuss parts of books they particularly enjoyed, and the researchers could communicate directly with students to give them praise for a job well done. In a case described by Liqing and Bouleware (2002), second-grade students came to class excited to find out if “I have a message from Dr. Boulware or Dr. Tao?” and, then when an e-mail arrived, “Look, Dr. Boulware says she likes my book.”

These young students made progress in more than just mastery of the skill of using e-mail, but in sentence structure and general communication of their ideas. As one low achieving student wrote at the beginning of the study, “My favort book is ACROSS THE STREAM By Mirra Ginsburg. You shude try to read this book it is a very, very good book becouas it has good character’s” (Liqing & Bouleware, 2002). Later in the study, the same student wrote: “I am reading a book called NEVER SPIT ON YOUR SHOES it is a good book. It has good characters like the other book. Called ACROSS THE STREAM. My favrorrit chater is a mouse but it didn’t minchin his name” (Liqing & Boulware, 2002, p. 287). While the spelling did not improve much, the ability to communicate definitely improved. The positive self-image of the student shows through. The sentence structure and general composition of the paragraph is a great improvement in the later communication. This student will move toward college with a confidence and ability in e-mail communication that will aid in distance education, if the student chooses that path.

In another instance, a distance learning program was set up to give a diploma in probation studies. There were three loops in preparing for this degree program. The first, as expected, was technology, the second was issues related to the university, and the third was trainee issues. The third loop included evidence of a lack of confidence in e-mail use, not only on the part of the students, but also on the part of the administrators:

As we are unsure if and when trainees will pick up e-mails, the Programme Administrator and I are currently backing up all messages with a hard copy. Obviously, this is defeating the purpose of e-mail and inadvertently undermining this approach! (Sunderland, 2002)

In addition to a lack of experience with the art of e-mail communication, the students appear to have a lack of comfort with computer use in general. The only solution this institution came up with was discussing the problem with managers and placing the problem on the continuing problem list.

An article from the University of Nebraska at Omaha discusses some scenarios of miscommunication through e-mail and offers a five-step solution for adults learning this new technique that consists of five questions. Their model focuses on problem solving; however, if authors of e-mails will ask themselves similar simple questions when sending out electronic communication, many instances of miscommunication could be avoided. The five questions are:

  • Question 1: what is the problem?

  • Question 2: what makes it a problem?

  • Question 3: what can be done?

  • Question 4: what should be done?

  • Question 5: what will be done? (Grandgenett & Grandgenett, 2001)

Alternate questions could include: What is the purpose of this message? Why am I sending this message? Does this message clearly state my thoughts? Is my intent clear? If the e-mail communication can clearly answer these questions, it has a greater chance of being a successful e-mail.

The need for education on effective e-mail communication is a problem that cannot be ignored as the field of education moves more and more toward electronic means for education. As a short-term solution, simple procedures should be provided to each student taking classes requiring e-mail communication. These simple procedures cannot replace actual training, but can assist the struggling student. Included in the simple procedures should be such things as:

  • Making a final reading of the message, reading from the point of view of the receiver.

  • Asking yourself: Is the tone okay? Can it be misinterpreted? Have I clearly stated what is intended?

Until student education on appropriate and effective computer use is an integral part of all education, students must be self-motivated to find out for themselves how to effectively communicate by e-mail.

A portrait of Sandi Grandberry with text identifying her as an Adjunct Professor at Phoenix College and San Joaquin Delta College, including her address, phone number, and email.
Sandi Grandberry, Adjunct Professor, Phoenix College, and Online Adjunct Professor at San Jaquin Delta College, 5130 W. Baseline, Ste. 117-16, Laveen, AZ 85339. Telephone: (602) 617-3374.

Grandgenett
N.
Grandgenett
D.
(
2001
).
Problem resolution through Electronic mail: a five-step model
.
Innovations in Education & Teaching International
,
38
(
4
),
347
.
[On-line]. Retrieved June 26, 2003 from http://web.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdf?vid=23&hid=120&sid=1903dcf1-7f9e-4f62-b5a8-9aa053261a31%40sessionmgr104
Liqing
T.
Boulware
B.
(
2002
).
Issues in technology e-mail: Instructional potentials and learning opportunities
.
Reading and Writing Quarterly
,
18
(
3
),
285
288
.
Sunderland
J.
(
2002
).
New communication practices, identity and the psychological gap: the effective function of e-mail on a distance doctoral programme
.
Studies in Higher Education
,
27
(
2
),
233
.
[On-line]. Retrieved June 26, 2003, from http://web.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdf?vid=28&hid=120&sid=1903dcf1-7f9e-4f62-b5a8-9aa053261a31%40sessionmgr104
Licensed re-use rights only

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal